ROTOWIRE.COM NFL MLB / Minors NBA NHL GOLF RACING    COMMUNITY FORUMS PODCASTS MYROTOWIRE ASK AN EXPERT GAMES

What is Gilbert Arenas' trade value?

It is always difficult to value a superstar player who has been hit by injuries, and Gilbert Arenas is no exception.  In 2006 Arenas was a potential top-5 pick in fantasy drafts, but after missing 147 games to injury over the last two seasons he slid in most drafts this year.  Now, five games in, how do you value him?

At first blush, Arenas' numbers thus far this season look a lot like his peak numbers.  But look a little closer:

2005-06: 29.3 points, 44.7% FG, 6.0 assists, 2.5 treys, 3.5 boards, 2.0 steals
2006-07: 28.4 points, 41.8% FG, 6.0 assists, 2.8 treys, 4.5 boards, 1.9 steals

2009-10: 27.6 points, 43.6% FG, 5.6 assists, 2.0 treys, 2.6 boards, 1.0 steals

Arenas' points, shooting percentages and assists are all similar.  But what really put his value over the top a few years ago  were his treys and steals.  Thus far Arenas is down almost a full trey and almost a full steal from what he produced at his peak.  When you factor in that he is also down a couple of rebounds from where he was, his value takes a solid hit even from his on-court production.  If he continues as is he will still be great, definitely more valuable than his 30.8 Yahoo! ADP, but not quite what he was before.

Then, you have to factor in the injury history.  Arenas is playing at a much higher level this season than he did at any point in the last two years, but it is still worrying that he had to miss so much time and kept re-aggravating that injury.  The injury risk was not enough to discourage me from taking him in the second or third round of a few drafts, but it would give me pause from making him my best player.

Bottom line, I currently rank Gilbert in the 10 - 20 range.  I wouldn't trade Deron Williams or Chris Bosh to get him, but I wouldn't trade Arenas for Al Jefferson, Chauncey Billups or even Steve Nash.  While I pay attention to injury risk, I am more concerned with what I see on the court.  And if Arenas starts adding that third trey and second steal it is possible that he moves further up my list.  For now, I love the idea of him as my second best player but I still worry a bit if he is the main guy.

Comments

By: smckeown
On: 11/6/2009 2:56:00 PM		 I like your rank of Arenas in the 10-20 range. I wouldn't trade him for Jefferson, Billups or Nash either, but if I could land Melo or Roy, I'd do it in a heartbeat.
 
By: Chris Liss
On: 11/6/2009 6:48:00 PM		 I'd probably take Nash over him when you factor in the injury risk.
 

Leave a comment

Commenting is restricted to registered users only. Please register or login now to submit a comment.

Tell Someone

  • Digg it
  • submit to reddit reddit
  • Add to Mixx!

Recent Favorites

NFL Notes
A look around the league regarding Week 10:
Week 10 Observations
  • We've beaten to death Bill Belichick's decision to go for it on 4th and 2 in Sunday night's game (the best take on it I've seen is here), but the real takeaway is how much Cris Collinsworth, Al Michaels, Tony Dungy and Rodney Harrison felt it was their duty to spout the conventional wisdom without even attempting to analyze Belichick's basis for the decision. Throw in Bob Costas, and it's appalling that five guys collectively making more than $10 million a year to interpret the sport for us didn't even consider the issue from a probability standpoint. Sadly, the NBC crew is probably the best one on TV. (Update: Jon Gruden just defended Belichick's call on MNF - good for him).
    • Dominant Offense but Shaky Defense...Barkley and Dirk
    This topic is a spin-off from the Michael Jordan thread of last week.  In the excellent discussion on that thread a mini-debate broke out as to how Charles Barkley compares to Kevin Garnett.  The gist of the brief debate was to question whether Barkley was enough better than Garnett offensively to make them comparable in value as overall players despite Garnett’s huge defensive advantages.  The thing is, though, to me there is a much better comp for Barkley in this generation than Garnett:  Dirk Nowitzki.
    What is Iverson's Legacy?
    What are we talking 'bout? We're talking 'bout *IVERSON*.
    Jennings vs Rose
    Last year Derrick Rose was the NBA Rookie of the Year.  One year later, would you take him over current rookie point guard phenom Brandon Jennings?

    RSS Feeds