The Indians Have Totally Mismanaged Matt LaPorta

The Cleveland Indians have earned their position as a last place club.

The way they have handled Matt LaPorta is actually beyond belief. Why in the world did they sign Russell Branyan over the winter to play first base? Especially since Branyan had a history of back problems. Especially when they had played LaPorta at first base in the minor leagues in 2009 with the intention and publicly stated plan of turning first base over to LaPorta in the 2010 season. Especially when they could have had LaPorta at first learning to hit big league pitching while the team was headed to oblivion.

Back to Branyan. He didn't play in spring training because he was still rehabbing from the back problems that kept him out of the Seattle Mariners lineup the second half of '09. When asked during spring training when Branyan would get into a game, the Indians front office kept saying they wanted him totally healthy when he did play. Spring training lasted from February until April. In essence, the Indians signed an injured player to take over a position earmarked for the prize of their trade for Cy Young winner C.C. Sabathia. LaPorta was pushed aside in favor of a player who couldn't play. A player known for hitting long home runs with a propensity for striking out. A lot. LaPorta's development was delayed another half season so Branyan could play first base.

LaPorta did not have tremendous success during limited opportunities with the major league club. However, when called up in 2009, LaPorta got to watch baseball from his semi- permanent seat on the bench. That's when he should have been in AAA. Not this year. If they were going to bring him up in '09, let him play. When he played with the Tribe in '10, he struggled. Again, he wasn't playing on a regular basis. So they sent him out for even more seasoning. Now he's hitting .353 with 5 homers and 16 RBI. In short, there were two crucial mistakes in his development. First, bringing him to the big leagues in '09 and letting him sit on the bench when he could have been playing in AAA. Second, not bringing him up in '10 and allowing him to see major league pitching on a team solidly entrenched in the basement of its division.

So now Branyan has been traded back to Seattle and they can deal with his troublesome back. Again. What a waste of a half season. Why the lowly Mariners need him at this point is beyond me. But off Branyan goes to the northwest to help the Mariners. Seattle was kind enough to allow the Indians to pay for his rehab so he could return to the Mariners a little bit healthier.

Brantley is another story. The Indians blocked his emergence on the big league scene for the presence of Austin Kearns.

Kearns is having a nice year and I'm not as critical of his acquisition. I have always felt that Kearns had potential when healthy. He has some power and he and Shin-Soo Choo represent the only proven pop the Indians have on an everyday basis. I do think that Brantley needed more minor league seasoning.

The Indians have been a doormat since their fantastic teams of the 90's. They tore the heart and soul from their club with the trading of Sabathia, Cliff Lee and Victor Martinez. Those were their core players. Those were true stars.

One would think that trading major pieces of an organization would yield outstanding prospects, if not major league ready players. That has not been the case with Cleveland. No superstars appear on the horizon from the multiple deals that shed the team of payroll. Not one. LaPorta could be an average player at first base. Brantley could become an average player in the outfield. All the pitching the club received in return for the countless players traded are still learning and treading water. Justin Masterson is improving. The rest are having difficulty or are terribly inconsistent in the minor leagues.

It's very difficult to watch an organization self- destruct. However, Indians fans have watched a once proud franchise crumble due to poor first year player drafts, poor payroll management and a constant desire to pay for fading players hoping the team has uncovered a hidden gem that every other team has passed over. Then the Indians can trade those fading gems to another club and reap mediocre fringe players to fill out minor league rosters in return.

And so here comes Matt LaPorta once again. After his club has mismanaged his development, he has the opportunity to play first base on an everyday basis in Cleveland. Perhaps. I hope he does well. He deserves success.

I don't know if the players received for Branyan from Seattle will help in the future. My focus when I heard about the trade was to think of the wasted time for both Russell Branyan and Matt LaPorta. Perhaps the Tribe has picked up two useful players. They still owe Seattle another player of some money. So the deal isn't complete as of this writing.

Here is what I do know. The Indians brass somehow feels they can take washed up players and turn their careers around They feel they have the elixir to turn a sow's ear to a silk purse. But in the past 10 years, all that's left from the reclamation projects has been the stench of the barnyard. It's time to clean out the barn.


By: Janet Eagleson
On: 6/27/2010 4:31:00 PM
Bernie, how far "behind" (in terms of development) do you think LaPorta is given the Indians mis-management? And do you think there's any hope he'll become the quasi-stud he was projected to be when he was drafted?
By: Bernie Pleskoff
On: 6/27/2010 5:23:00 PM
Janet- I think he's missed a half season of big league pitching. I think he'll spend the rest of the season catching up. I regret I've never felt that LaPorta was a major prospect. I think he's an average player or a "50" on the scouting grading scale-every day average player. I think his power may develop over time, but he'll have to learn to adjust to pitchers making adjustments to him. Finally, I think we may see streaks of very good at-bats with good results and streaks when he looks like he doesn't have a clue.---Bernie
By: lvtdude
On: 6/28/2010 1:41:00 AM
I see LaPorta having an Aubrey Huff-type career. Would you say that's fair?
By: tourinct
On: 6/28/2010 2:15:00 AM
At least the Blake for Santana deal looks OK.
By: Bernie Pleskoff
On: 6/28/2010 7:11:00 AM
lvtdude- I think that's an outstanding comparison.---Bernie

tourinct- Your right, that was a winner (for both sides I might add) But the results for Sabathia, Lee and Martinez are underwhelming so far, to say the least. ---Bernie
By: lvtdude
On: 6/28/2010 12:27:00 PM
Thanks, Bernie. I wonder if LaPorta will be better off this time around, with a minor-league teammate of his (Santana) playing so well. Sometimes guys feed off each other's success.
By: Bernie Pleskoff
On: 6/28/2010 2:06:00 PM
lvidude- I'm a big believer in protection in a batting order. Choo and Santana will help, but the Indians are very shallow in terms of depth up and down the lineup. I'm not sure LaPorta will see many great pitches per at-bat. That could lead to poor pitch selection and negative results. I don't think Hafner can be viewed as protection even though he's improving.---Bernie
By: Erickson
On: 6/28/2010 10:57:00 PM
The Tribe seems to do better on their smaller trades under the current mgmt than their marquee deals. Getting Choo and Druby for Broussard and Eduardo Perez in separate deals in one season was Grand Theft Bavasi, and I think Santana for a half-season of Blake (remember, the Dodgers had to re-sign him) is going to end up looking pretty sweet too. Wasn't the Colon heist also under Shapiro's watch, at the beginning of his tenure? It's just too bad they never struck gold in the draft, at least recently.
By: Bernie Pleskoff
On: 6/29/2010 6:29:00 AM
Erickson- I'd say the Colon trade (Sizemore, Lee) was Shapiro's best. Personally, it was free falll after that.
Yes, there have been some good trades among the many, but when you trade stars and franchise players, at least one or two above major league average players should come back in return. Bavasi had a very bad track record in trades (the Orioles deal being the worst) and the Mariners didn't put up with it. Not so with the Indians. Shapiro still rules. Go figure.

Leave a comment

Commenting is restricted to registered users only. Please register or login now to submit a comment.

Tell Someone

  • Digg it
  • submit to reddit reddit
  • Add to Mixx!

Recent Favorites

What I Think You Should Know About The USMNT
Needless to say, it's been a great World Cup thus far. The USMNT having some success would be awesome.
La-La-La-L.A. Gets Lord Stanley!
Just a few things that caught my eye:
  • Alec Martinez's Cup-winning goal celebration? # priceless. I wonder if he'll ever get his gloves back.
  • Henrik Lundqvist stopped the 50th shot of the game. He couldn't stop the 51st. #connsmythe if the Rangers had found a way to come back in this series.
Do Analytics Take the Fun Out of Sports?
Apparently that was the topic of one of the presentations at the Sloan Sports Analytics Conference in Boston last week. The presenter, Yale's Edward Tufte, opined:

Don't let people tell you analytics are reductionist and take the joy out of sports. They mostly just take the stupidity out of sports.

Is he right?

RotoWire's AL LABR Squad
The 2014 AL LABR auction went down at the Arizona Republic offices in downtown Phoenix Saturday night. It's a 12-team, 5 x 5, AL-only league with 2 C, 1 1B, 1 2B. 1 3B, 1 SS, 1 CI, 1 MI, 5 OF, 1 U and 9 pitchers. Everyone has $260 to spend.
The Problem With Drafting Billy Hamilton
Billy Hamilton went for $28 in the NL LABR auction this past weekend. I discussed this with a fellow writer who participates in Tout Wars with me later this month and we discussed the problem with investing heavily into Hamilton.

RSS Feeds